Jeanine Pirro’s DOJ Indictment Bid Collapses After ‘Unlawful Orders’ Video Probe
A D.C. grand jury declined to indict six Democratic lawmakers after federal prosecutors sought charges tied to a video urging troops to refuse unlawful orders. The decision matters now because it leaves the Justice Department facing questions about why the case was pushed in the first place.
The central tension is that, even as the probe escalated, defense lawyers and some reporting say prosecutors struggled to identify what specific law the lawmakers supposedly broke. That gap is now becoming the focus, not just the video itself.
People and Military.com reported U.S. Attorney Jeanine Pirro’s office pursued indictments against Sen. Elissa Slotkin, Sen. Mark Kelly, and four House Democrats who appeared in a November PSA. The video referenced military obligations around unlawful orders and did not name a specific order to disobey.
The Washington Post reported Slotkin’s team met with prosecutors and came away saying the government could not clearly describe a criminal theory or cite a statute at issue. The New Republic separately reported prosecutors could not name a statute when asked, citing sources familiar with the discussions.
Former U.S. Attorney Preet Bharara said prosecutors “could not articulate any theory of possible criminal liability” or identify a statute that could have been violated.
The fallout is already spilling into other arenas. A federal judge recently blocked the Pentagon’s attempt to punish Kelly over the same video, ruling the move violated his First Amendment rights.
Related: GOP Judiciary Plan Would Let Trump Evade Court Orders, Critics Say
For Pirro’s office, the next question is whether prosecutors try to revise the theory and return to a grand jury, or quietly drop the effort after the public defeat. Coverage has noted a renewed attempt is possible, but not confirmed as imminent.
For now, the case has produced a headline outcome without a charge—exactly the outcome the lawmakers say proves the inquiry never had a legal foundation.
Related: Federal Judge Forces DOJ to Unseal Affidavit Tied to FBI’s Fulton County Raid