No Kings, No Chaos: A Movement of Millions Finds Its Voice
Millions March, not for a Moment, but for a Movement
I spent most of October 18 watching the No Kings protest unfold in Washington, D.C. I had braced for disruption — maybe violence, maybe confusion, maybe another hopeful crowd worn down by division. However, what I saw was something different. From a trans veteran in uniform to Bill Nye warning about science denialism, from the cofounders of the Free D.C. movement calling for statehood to the Indivisible crew, the voices that took the stage weren’t just speaking. They were listening, connecting, and building.
It wasn’t just D.C. That same sense of coordination, clarity, and care echoed from small towns in Michigan to sprawling demonstrations in Chicago, Houston, and New York. It was a moment that shouldn’t have been possible, and yet it happened.
Because democracy doesn’t defend itself, and neither does your sanity. Subscribe here to keep your eyes open and your sarcasm sharp.
A Scale That Staggered
Organizers estimate more than 7 million people participated in No Kings protests across 2,600+ cities and towns in all 50 states. In New York City alone, more than 100,000 people marched. Houston saw over 13,000. Smaller towns, such as Manistee County, Michigan, and Alton, Illinois, reported hundreds turning out where sometimes only dozens are expected. Even my small rural county showed up, bringing hundreds out despite living in deep red country.
While exact numbers remain subject to verification, even conservative estimates place this among the largest nationwide protest mobilizations in U.S. history. We waited to recap until the weekend had ended to try to capture the latest numbers and stories for completeness.
Discipline Was the Story
The real surprise, though, wasn’t the turnout. It was the peace.
There were no arrests reported in New York City or Boston, and just one in Los Angeles. That is extraordinary. Twelve protest-related arrests were reported in Denver, the highest of any city, and still a fraction of the crowd size. One man in Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania, was arrested after brandishing a firearm near the crowd, a reminder of the ever-present threat of provocation, but even there, the crowd remained calm, and police quickly handled the situation.
This wasn’t by chance. Organizers across the country trained participants in nonviolence and de-escalation, with marshals and community safety teams working the crowds. This echoed the strategies of the George Floyd-era protests, where frontline participants took responsibility for the tone, message, and safety of the movement. Peer-to-peer self-policing has proven to be highly effective and prevents small sparks from turning into a roaring inferno.
A Chorus of Voices
From D.C. to Des Moines, the protests showcased coalition-building at its best. Speakers and signs represented a wide spectrum of causes: trans rights, immigrant justice, racial equity, climate action, reproductive autonomy, and opposition to war and occupation.
In D.C., speakers acknowledged hard truths, especially historic tensions with Black communities who have often been asked to show up for others, only to be left behind in return. This time, those voices were not only present — they were centered. That shift was long overdue, and it was noticed.
We’ve Been Here Before
American protest history is filled with moments of mass mobilization that burned bright and fast and then fizzled. What made the Civil Rights Movement of the 1960s endure wasn’t just its scale. It was its strategy, discipline, and moral clarity. The same was true of early labor movements, the original women’s marches, and even the most sustained moments of the George Floyd uprisings.
The No Kings protests now face the same test. A protest is not a movement unless it keeps moving.
Unity over Uniformity
There were calls, especially online, for a general strike in conjunction with the protests. While these gained momentum on social media, there’s little evidence of coordinated strike action on the ground. That’s not surprising. As we’ve reported before, the United States has virtually no legal or structural pathway to a general strike. The Taft-Hartley Act and decades of anti-union policy have left American labor fragmented and reactive by design.
See our previous reporting here:
But the energy is there, and it can grow — if channeled.
The key now is resisting the wedges that have so often split progressive movements: identity, tactics, terminology. We don’t need unanimity to fight authoritarianism. We need clarity of purpose. That is why No Kings was so effective. It rallied disparate coalitions under one umbrella.
Global Solidarity
Support didn’t stop at the U.S. border. In London, Berlin, and Tokyo, small solidarity protests gathered outside U.S. embassies and public squares. Organized by chapters of Democrats Abroad and local activist networks, these international rallies reminded us that what’s happening in the United States matters everywhere. Democracy’s erosion in one country — especially this country — reverberates globally.
What Happens Next
The No Kings protests were one of the largest, most peaceful protest mobilizations in modern American history. However, they will only matter if we make them matter.
That means showing up when the cameras are off. It means building coalitions that don’t dissolve at the first disagreement. It means listening to those who’ve been doing this work for decades. It means registering voters, protecting poll workers, resisting misinformation, and having hard conversations, especially with people we’re told are “on the other side.” Everyone who is hurt by the policies and trajectory of this country can be part of the movement forward to something better. We only have to agree on one thing: THIS is not our America, and we will fight to get her back.
This isn’t just about Trump, or the courts, or even one party. This is about the soul of a democracy, and whether we believe it’s still ours to shape.
Don’t let the bastards sneak anything past you. Subscribe and get your daily dose of rage and receipts delivered fresh, before the spin doctors can scrub it.
Sources:
“‘No Kings’ protests pass in festival atmosphere as nearly 7 million rally across US” – The Independent
“Organizers say over 7 million showed up to No Kings protests” – The Verge
“‘No Kings’ protests against Trump bring a street‑party vibe to cities nationwide” – Politico
“Man arrested after allegedly flashing gun at ‘No Kings’ protest in Wilkes‑Barre” – Fox56 WOLF
“NYPD estimates more than 100‑thousand protesters flood NYC streets for ‘No Kings’ march” – ABC7 New York
“‘People have had it’: No Kings protests inspire Bay Area crowds, exceed expectations” – San Francisco Chronicle
“Midland’s No Kings Day draws 1,400 to protest Trump” – Midland Daily News
“Manistee County Democrats say 925 attended protest” – Manistee News Advocate
This was a great weekend - a time to see Americans at their finest - standing up for democracy in a peaceful way - letting our voices be heard - making it clear we are watching and we demand better.
I hope your voices will be heard. 🙏