5 Comments
User's avatar
Joyce Krachmalnick's avatar

We spend $5.3 trillion a year on healthcare, and still too many of us ask "what will it cost?" before we ask "what is wrong?"

That is $15,474 for every person in America, yet 30 million of us will go without insurance in an average month this year.

We do not need free everything or the end of private insurance. We need a floor, a clear guarantee of basic care beneath the system we already pay for.

Read the full essay, then go to senate.gov and tell your senators that Congress should write this guarantee.

We are America, and no one among us should face a diagnosis afraid of the bill.

Joyce Krachmalnick's avatar

This sounds like a good starting point. Is there anyone in Congress who is ready to write, promote, file, and bring this up for a vote?

Alan Goldhammer's avatar

I was hospitalized in Ireland for complications of Covid. The bill: zero even tho I was an American. In this country it would cost thousands unless there was expensive insurance. The health cost situation in the U.S. is just cruel and disgraceful.

Beth Jane Freeman's avatar

This would insure people got regular screenings, vaccinations and other preventative measures like blood pressure, cholesterol checks, etc. We can pass this right away, and then continue to press for Medicare for All. The big uphill battle against Medicare for All are the drug companies and the Health Insurance companies. They don’t want to cut into all those juicy profits!

Fred Jonas's avatar

I apologize for the long delay in getting around to this post.

I have discussed this matter many times. I am a medical doctor, and I've been one for over 49 years. The title you gave this post was "We Spend $5.3T on Health Care." In this country, we have the American medical industry. It is not "health care." It commonly has little or nothing to do with anyone's health. Its purpose is to move money from wherever it is to providers, other vendors, and insurance companies. Real countries have health care.

You have a section you entitle "We Are Already Paying For Health Care." No, we're not. We're paying for an industry that is unconnected to health care.

You should consider four facts: 1) we spend far more on the American medical industry than real countries spend on actual health care; 2) our results are worse than almost all developed countries. It is theoretically easy to explain the excessive cost, which you itemize: everyone charges too much for everything. That's part of the explanation. It's a lot more complicated to explain how we spend that much, and the result is worse than everyone else's. There are many parts to that dynamic. 3) We do not even provide whatever we provide to everyone. And 4), to illustrate part of the consequence of this corrupt dysfunction, the commonest cause of personal bankruptcy in this country is now, and has always been, an inability to pay medical bills.

You address superficial parts of the problem in your "The Price Comes After the Design" section.

As an aside, in your "The Hard Questions Cannot Be Waved Away" section, you mention shortening appointment calendars. This gives a peek at parts of the problem. How many people do you know who are terribly ill, and need frequent medical attention? If many or most of the people you know are not like that, how do waiting rooms get full to overflowing, so that a patient calling in, and especially a new patient, get told the next opening is in several weeks or so? It leaves open the possibility that someone is inventing something. And there's evidence that that is very true.

It's much more complicated than a guarantee, or stewardship, that the government could, as you seem almost glibly to suggest, manage. It is an entire restructuring, from the medical science part to the government part. We have experimented with parts of that, and they have been partially successful, because they were partial attempts to address the problems. The blockage is all the parts of the industry that pay off government functionaries (legislators) not to change anything.