One other concern is that our medical system is controlled by insurance or the government which means that when the doctor prescribes a particular treatment - if you can pay for it, you get the treatment; in our system, when the doctor prescribes the treatment, your insurance company or the government (Medicare or Medicaid) can still deny the treatment (because they pay for it) claiming it is excessive or unnecessary - adding a lot of administrative cost to the process. Maybe socialized medicine isn't so bad.
Socialized medicine, by whatever term anyone chooses to use, is what would save this country, and make it like a real country, with actual "health care." But Congress gets paid off not to let that happen, and the closest we've come, which was the ACA, was corrupted by retaining private insurance companies as the source of payment. They couldn't disqualify pre-existing conditions any more, and some people got help with premiums, but deductibles and copays still applied. People who can't afford the deductibles and copays have insurance, but they're not insured.
We need a program run only by the government, and we need people paying proper taxes to support the program.
If you haven't seen Michael Moore's "Sicko," I highly recommend it.
As far as Republicans are concerned, a benefit becomes socialism when it goes to the poor. If it goes to the morbidly wealthy, it's just plain old capitalism.
So do we also call the government giving certain companies massive subsidies that inflate their value and go directly to shareholders and not workers socialism? What about huge tax breaks that mostly benefit those whose income and/or net worth is 10x that of the rest of the country? Either way it is redistribution that doesn't help most of us.
Your set-up is good enough. It allows you to make the point you're proposing to make. There are just two problems that prevent one scenario from equaling the other.
One is that one arrangement allows recipients of this theoretical donation to spend the money any way he or she wants. The other arrangement keeps government involved, so that, for example, if a theoretical donation is proposed to be intended to fulfil one specific bill, the public has no reason to assume that some closed door dealing didn't mean that all the money went where it was said to be intended to go. For example, the current government said it was refunding tariff money, but it wound up refunding it to Wall St, not to the consumers who paid it.
The other problem, which I have said ad nauseum, is that any sentence that starts with "the clown said..." is a sentence not worth finishing. We've heard about a number of government boosts, and you've listed them, but no one has seen them. Whether it's a check on condition that a particular political party win, or prices that are said to be going to drop after the midterms, or anything, it's all just empty chatter. If you take someone known by the acronym "TACO," and add that that person is a flagrant and inveterate liar, these proposals of $5000 for this, $2000 for that, $90 for something else, have no meaning.
One other concern is that our medical system is controlled by insurance or the government which means that when the doctor prescribes a particular treatment - if you can pay for it, you get the treatment; in our system, when the doctor prescribes the treatment, your insurance company or the government (Medicare or Medicaid) can still deny the treatment (because they pay for it) claiming it is excessive or unnecessary - adding a lot of administrative cost to the process. Maybe socialized medicine isn't so bad.
Socialized medicine, by whatever term anyone chooses to use, is what would save this country, and make it like a real country, with actual "health care." But Congress gets paid off not to let that happen, and the closest we've come, which was the ACA, was corrupted by retaining private insurance companies as the source of payment. They couldn't disqualify pre-existing conditions any more, and some people got help with premiums, but deductibles and copays still applied. People who can't afford the deductibles and copays have insurance, but they're not insured.
We need a program run only by the government, and we need people paying proper taxes to support the program.
If you haven't seen Michael Moore's "Sicko," I highly recommend it.
As far as Republicans are concerned, a benefit becomes socialism when it goes to the poor. If it goes to the morbidly wealthy, it's just plain old capitalism.
So do we also call the government giving certain companies massive subsidies that inflate their value and go directly to shareholders and not workers socialism? What about huge tax breaks that mostly benefit those whose income and/or net worth is 10x that of the rest of the country? Either way it is redistribution that doesn't help most of us.
Your set-up is good enough. It allows you to make the point you're proposing to make. There are just two problems that prevent one scenario from equaling the other.
One is that one arrangement allows recipients of this theoretical donation to spend the money any way he or she wants. The other arrangement keeps government involved, so that, for example, if a theoretical donation is proposed to be intended to fulfil one specific bill, the public has no reason to assume that some closed door dealing didn't mean that all the money went where it was said to be intended to go. For example, the current government said it was refunding tariff money, but it wound up refunding it to Wall St, not to the consumers who paid it.
The other problem, which I have said ad nauseum, is that any sentence that starts with "the clown said..." is a sentence not worth finishing. We've heard about a number of government boosts, and you've listed them, but no one has seen them. Whether it's a check on condition that a particular political party win, or prices that are said to be going to drop after the midterms, or anything, it's all just empty chatter. If you take someone known by the acronym "TACO," and add that that person is a flagrant and inveterate liar, these proposals of $5000 for this, $2000 for that, $90 for something else, have no meaning.
this is thought-provoking, but it needed to be reduced by a third in length , at least